Book Review: ‘Romantic Comedy’ by Curtis Sittenfeld

Can a romantic comedy still surprise us in the age of dating apps, social media, and self-sabotage?
Curtis Sittenfeld’s Romantic Comedy doesn’t just follow the love story of an ordinary woman and a famous pop star—it deconstructs what we expect from romance, humor, and even ourselves. With clever writing, vulnerable characters, and a backdrop that mirrors real-world showbiz, this novel asks a simple yet powerful question: What happens when someone actually falls for the person we’re afraid to become?

A Fresh Take on Love, Humor, and Complexity

In Curtis Sittenfeld’s Romantic Comedy, the story centers around Sally Milz, a 36-year-old writer for the sketch comedy show The Night Owls, which mirrors the behind-the-scenes chaos of Saturday Night Live. Sally, a mild-mannered woman with insecurities, juggles her romantic prospects alongside her work, often feeling like an outsider in the celebrity-filled world around her. Her life takes an unexpected turn when she begins a budding romance with a famous singer, forcing her to confront her emotional barriers and personal biases. As the plot develops, it becomes clear that Sally’s journey is not just about love, but about finding her voice in a world driven by media and self-image.

Despite seeming mismatched at first, the chemistry between Sally and her love interest feels authentic. Their dynamic explores the complexities of love and pride with a tone that’s both light and playful. Romance, Comedy, and Unexpected Treasures shine through in this novel, which isn’t just a love story—it’s a romantic comedy about writing, ambition, and connection, with Sittenfeld blending humor and sharp social commentary. Offering romantic intrigue and insights into the challenges of modern fame, this book is an engaging read for anyone who enjoys love stories, creative work, and a touch of wit.

Behind the Scenes of ‘Romantic Comedy’

In Romantic Comedy, Sittenfeld takes us behind the curtain of a fast-paced New York sketch show resembling Saturday Night Live. Sally, a thirtysomething writer, finds herself immersed in the chaos of her creative life—bouncing between pitch meetings and exhausting after-after-parties. Her social life consists of fleeting dating app encounters until Noah Brewster, a heartthrob pop star and guest host of the show, starts to show interest in her. As their relationship begins to unfold, Sally struggles with self-doubt and skepticism, convinced it won’t last despite their growing connection.

Sittenfeld skillfully explores the psychology of “outsiders” and how even the most unexpected pairings can lead to something real. The book also highlights the subtle reversal of the usual Hollywood trope—portraying a charming, successful man with an “average-looking” yet confident and self-aware woman. It’s a story of contrast—balancing writing advice with emotional connection, and ambition with vulnerability—making it a compelling and emotionally resonant read.

Sally and Noah’s Relationship Journey

Sally soon finds herself in a classic romantic comedy scenario with Noah, a charismatic and self-deprecating guest host of The Night Owls. Their relationship begins with flirtation, mishaps, and witty banter, all while navigating the challenges of the pandemic. The email exchanges between them offer an intimate look at their developing bond, adding depth and authenticity. As Sally’s feelings grow, she sabotages their chances with biting remarks about models and romantic clichés, revealing her fear of vulnerability. The slower-paced middle section, focused on their email correspondence, highlights Sally’s emotional growth while testing her trust and self-belief.

Sittenfeld captures the tension and unpredictability of modern relationships through sharp dialogue and thoughtful pacing. Despite a hesitant start, Sally and Noah’s love story is filled with humor, warmth, and relatability, making the novel a heartfelt exploration of connection and self-discovery.

Unique Characters and Relationships

In Romantic Comedy, Sally navigates a whirlwind of challenges typical of the genre—unexpected love, personal doubt, and the influence of public image. At the same time, she tries to balance her ambition with her feelings for Noah, all while dealing with the pressures of social media and the complexities of the pandemic. Through thoughtful reflections on past relationships, Sally questions whether every love story needs a perfect, traditional ending. As her email communication with Noah deepens, their bond grows stronger—even when awkwardness, physical insecurities, and social differences threaten to get in the way.

The novel explores themes like emotional friction, media influence, and the tension between youth and maturity. With clever commentary on celebrity culture and the quirks of modern romance, Romantic Comedy leaves readers reflecting on their own emotional patterns and expectations in love.

Final Thoughts

Romantic Comedy by Curtis Sittenfeld is more than a love story—it’s a sharp, funny, and heartfelt exploration of what it means to be vulnerable in a world obsessed with perfection. Through Sally and Noah’s journey, the novel reminds us that love doesn’t always look like a fairytale, and that’s exactly what makes it real.

Whether you’re a fan of romance, comedy, or stories about writers navigating life and love, this book offers an honest take that feels fresh and surprisingly relatable. It’s a charming read for anyone who’s ever doubted they were enough—and needed someone to prove them wrong.